Feb 2, 2020 Wisdom/Foolishness
This morning, I
would like to tell you about a Scottish theologian named Pelagian. Pelagian
believed that God had given us the church in order to perfect humankind. And
Pelagian believed that by making men and women moral, that that would achieve
God’s purpose. Now a group of Pelagian’s followers decided to put his theology
into practice. First of all they got rid of their priests, who didn’t meet up
with their standards, and then they encouraged all the parishes in their
diocese to do the same. Finally, they got rid of their bishop, and found one
that more lived up to their ideals. At this, the followers of Pelagian
rejoiced, they announced themselves free of the Catholic church, and set about
to make all the men and women in their parish more moral people.
Problem is, that
within 40 years, all of the churches who had left the Catholic church at that
time, had given up on Pelagianism and had returned to the Catholic church.
Writing at the time, St. Augustine gave his reason why this happened, because
the followers of Pelagian had replaced the crucified Christ as the head of the
church, with an image of their own moral purity. Under these conditions, they
no longer had any good news to preach to those who were broken, hurting, or
lost. All they had was condemnation, division and death.
The reason I am
bringing this up this week is because of our reading from 1 Corinthians this
morning. A lot of the problem the Corinthians are having is about some members
putting themselves above other members, and some members judging the worthiness
of other members to participate in the life of the church. And to those members
who are making these distinctions, Paul preaches Christ crucified, a stumbling
block to the Jews, and foolishness to the Gentiles. What? What does that mean?
In case I haven’t
said it before, Jesus Christ is a stumbling block to the Jews because he was
denounced as a blashphemer and cursed for being hung on a tree – the cross. So,
how could a righteous Jew, the keeper of God’s moral law, follow such a sinner.
And Jesus Christ is foolishness to the Gentiles, because he was a loser – he
stood up to Rome and got crucified for it – it would be foolishness to follow
someone like him. In saying these things about Jesus, Paul is trying to tell
the Corinthians that in playing these moral games, in playing the games of
winners and losers, that they are sowing divisions among themselves, which in
the light of Jesus Christ is true sin and true foolishness.
Now I have
preached many times on our gospel lesson this morning, often going through each
one of the beatitudes in order to understand them better, but in light of
Paul’s speech to the Corinthians this morning, this time I will take a general
approach to them. In general the beatitudes speak of the blessedness of
suffering the broken condition of humankind. Blessedness, because in the coming
of Jesus Christ, in the coming of God’s kingdom, these people who are sinners
and losers in the world, will know forgiveness and grace. They will obtain
mercy, they will be comforted, they will find peace, they will be satisfied,
they will see God. This is the same reversal of fortune that we find in Paul’s
letter to the Corinthians, for those who believe in Jesus Christ.